As My Father Always Said

Money Sense

"A Penny Saved Is a Penny Earned": Did Benjamin Franklin Really Say It?

Money Sense · 6 min read · 2026-10-05

Plenty of fathers have said it while flipping off a light switch or dropping a coin in a jar: "A penny saved is a penny earned." Most people give Benjamin Franklin the credit.

Published by The Dad Files. Editorial review by As My Father Always Said Editorial Desk.

Many a father has said it while flipping off a light switch or dropping a coin in a jar: "A penny saved is a penny earned." Most people give Benjamin Franklin the credit. Franklin printed something close. He didn't print that.

The version Franklin printed

Franklin published Poor Richard's Almanack every year from 1732 to 1758, under the pen name Richard Saunders. It was crammed with short sayings about thrift and work. In the 1737 edition, the line people cite most often reads: "A penny saved is two pence clear."

That's close to the modern saying, but it isn't the same. And by Franklin's own account, he gathered a lot of Poor Richard's sayings from older sources instead of making them up himself.

The older English versions

The idea was already making the rounds in England more than a century before that. The poet and priest George Herbert put a version in his collection of proverbs, Outlandish Proverbs, published in 1640: "A penny spar'd is twice got."

Other seventeenth-century writers used similar wording. The exact modern phrasing, "a penny saved is a penny earned," seems to have settled into common use later, and it got pinned to Franklin's name because his almanac made thrift sayings famous in America.

What the saying actually means

The logic is sharper than it first looks. Money you earn often gets taxed and comes with costs attached, like getting to work. Money you don't spend is already yours. So a saved penny can be worth as much as an earned one, or more.

That's the point behind Herbert's "twice got" and Franklin's "two pence clear": saving isn't some lesser cousin of earning. It's another way of getting ahead.

Why fathers love it

Part of the appeal is that it turns small actions into something that matters. A child can't earn much, but a child can save. The proverb gives them a way to pitch in.

It also fits a certain kind of household wisdom: fixing things instead of replacing them, packing a lunch, buying the sturdy boots that last. Those habits rarely feel heroic. The saying makes them count.

Father Abraham and The Way to Wealth

Franklin's best known statement on thrift is not a single proverb but a speech. In the preface to the 1758 almanac, Poor Richard Improved, he invented an old man called Father Abraham who stands before a crowd at an auction and answers their complaints about hard times by quoting Poor Richard back to them, saying after saying. The piece was reprinted on its own as The Way to Wealth and became one of the most widely circulated things Franklin ever wrote. The Library of Congress lists it among the books that shaped America.

Read today, the speech is less about pinching pennies than about attention. Father Abraham warns his listeners that small, regular leaks sink great ships, that buying what you do not need will soon force you to sell what you do need, and that a habit of borrowing gives other people power over your time. Thrift, in his telling, is a form of independence.

That framing matters for how fathers use the line. "A penny saved" is rarely about the penny. It is about learning to notice where money goes, and about the freedom that comes from not needing to ask anyone for it.

Franklin put his own money behind the idea

Franklin did not leave thrift as a slogan. In a 1789 codicil to his will, he left 1,000 pounds each to the cities of Boston and Philadelphia, to be lent at interest to young married craftsmen starting out in business. The funds were meant to grow for two hundred years, with part of the money released for public works after the first century and the remainder after the second.

The experiment did not go exactly as planned. Lending to apprentices dwindled as the trades changed, and the totals fell short of Franklin's projections. But the money did compound for two centuries, and by the 1990s both funds had grown into the millions of dollars. In Boston, part of the money helped establish what is now the Benjamin Franklin Institute of Technology. It is hard to think of a better illustration of the proverb: a modest sum, left alone, outlived its donor by two hundred years and kept working.

The arithmetic behind the saying

The claim that a saved penny can be worth more than an earned one holds up when you run the numbers. Suppose someone pays a combined 25 percent in income and payroll taxes on extra wages. To have one more dollar to spend, they need to earn about $1.33 before tax. Skipping a one dollar purchase gets them to the same place without the extra work.

Saving early adds a second effect. Money set aside and invested grows on its own returns over time, so a small amount saved at twenty can end up larger than a bigger amount saved at forty. The exact figures depend on returns, which are never guaranteed, but the direction is the point Herbert and Franklin were making: a coin kept is a coin that can keep working.

Where the proverb can mislead

Like most proverbs, this one has limits. Saving a few cents by driving across town for cheaper gas, or by skipping a needed repair, can cost more than it saves. Frugality that ignores time, health or safety is not thrift. Franklin's own advice was built around industry as well as frugality, and Father Abraham spends as much time urging hard work as he does warning against waste. The fuller lesson is to spend deliberately, not to spend nothing.

A modern twist

These days the same idea turns up in personal finance advice as "pay yourself first." The coins have changed. The U.S. Mint stopped striking pennies for circulation in November 2025, after each one cost more than a cent to make. The principle has outlived the coin.

How to pass it on

Sources

#Money Sense

Recommended on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Back to The Dad Files